Jeff Nottingham, MDiv, MA, LMHC

Clinical Director

Jeff specializes in working with couples who are in the various stages and transitions of their relationship. He sees couples in every phase of their relationship-- pre-engagement; pre-marital; newlywed; parenting; blended families; divorce recovery; empty-nesting; aging, etc. Jeff also works extensively with men who want to improve in a wide variety of personal areas, such as relational, sexual, spiritual, and/or vocational.

Jeff's approach to counseling starts and stops with a Christian worldview that incorporates two main emphases: existential counseling, which deals with the basic quest of life to find significance and security, and communication skills, which deal with the basic need of life to communicate well within our significant relationships. His professional but empathetic perspective raises questions and answers for his clients to work through with him and also with other trusted people in their lives.

Jeff received his MDiv and MA from Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis, MO, in 2012; he has been counseling in Indianapolis since then.

Laura Ferguson, MA, LMHC


Laura believes that people are communal beings who experience healing through others. Because of this, she cultivates strong client relationships, which are vital for recovery. She believes that individuals need to be balanced between family, work and community and she strives to help individuals become more connected in all of these spheres. She seeks to understand and help the client to clarify his/her values, prioritize goals and set healthy boundaries in life.

Laura received her Master of Arts in Counseling at Western Seminary and a Bachelor of Arts in English from James Madison University. She completed internships at Corban University, Salvation Army Adult Rehabilitation Center, and Lutheran Community Mental Health Services. She completed resident work at Johnson County Juvenile Detention Center, St. Roch School, Franklin High School, and Indiana University Hospital. She worked in private practice at Kenosis Counseling Center and also taught mental health and wellness classes for patients at Johnson Memorial Hospital.

Areas of clinical interest and specialty include depression, anxiety, life transitions and adjustments, grief, co-dependency, body image/weight loss and management, addiction, marital and relationship issues and spiritual/faith issues.

Kaylin Vincz, MA


Kaylin holds a Masters of Counseling degree from Westminster Theological Seminary and a Bachelor of Science in Biblical Counseling degree from Crossroads Bible College. She completed her internships at Twelve Stones Ministries and The Philadelphia Renewal Network. Kaylin's area's of interest include but are not limited to grief, anxiety, depression, addictions, sexual abuse and trauma, children and marriage counseling. 

Kaylin empathetically walks with you on your journey through counseling while applying a Biblical perspective to the challenges of life. In counseling she seeks to fully understand the lens through which a person views their world. Kaylin believes that it is in this vulnerability that Jesus reveals himself to be the source of love, security, significance, and strength. She believes Jesus' story, mapped onto ours has the power to change the way we view the world and that his presence gives the strength needed to face the challenges ahead. Kaylin believes relationships are the ministers of these realities. She provides a safe relationship within counseling and seeks to mend and strengthen other interpersonal relationships. 

Jason Pogue, MDiv, MA

Counselor, Teaching and Development Specialist

"Even under the best circumstances the world we live in can deliver us painful and confusing realities that we would not have chosen ourselves. When the people we love betray us, those in authority use it against us, and our minds and bodies seem to imprison us we often find ourselves stuck in places where we feel empty, overwhelmed, and hopeless."

"Wherever you are, I would be honored to join you there and walk alongside you toward a more life-giving place. Though the pain is incredibly real, so is the possibility of a more full and satisfying life."



Jason graduated with honors from Covenant Theological Seminary earning his Master of Divinity as well as his Master of Arts in Counseling. He practiced as a counselor in St. Louis prior to joining New Hope Counseling and has experience helping individuals, couples, and groups navigate the difficult terrain of various concerns such as anger, depression, anxiety, loneliness, grief, vocational struggles, sexual issues, family dynamics, past childhood abuse, identity/self-image, and spiritual struggles.


Jason is passionate about the healing work possible through interpersonal interactions of love, compassion, and presence between client and counselor, husband and wife, and between group members. He believes safe and secure relationships are the foundation for healing and care.


Jason holds advanced training through ICEEFT in Emotionally Focused Couples Therapy – the approach to couples therapy currently leading the field in positive outcome studies.